Can one story have too many puns?

We’ve come up with an idea on how to save the Philadelphia newspapers from bankruptcy.

Set a jar on the editor’s desk. Any time a reporter or editor uses a pun in a story or headline, have them drop a dollar in the jar.

0902lobsterlaugh

If this story in Tuesday’s Philadelphia Inquirer about a man who attempted to steal 91 lobsters from an Atlantic City casino eatery is any indication, the papers will be pulling a profit in no time.

The lede, by the Inky’s Peter Mucha:

No doubt the casino was steamed.

Mucha buckles down for eight sentences of straight newswriting. But then he succumbs to the dark side:

Soon the suspect found himself trapped, along with the young lobsters, and, as security guards tailing him muscled in to make the pinch, the man knew he was in hot water.

They’d quickly cracked the case.

Three more nut sentences and then a flourish to close:

The lobsters were worth an about $1,200, and that’s a lot of clams.

No word if Jones tried to butter up the judge.

Bally’s, by the way, is near the ocean, not the old bay.

Don’t get that last sentence? The restaurant robbed was at Bally’s casino, on the beachfront in Atlantic City. And “old bay” is a reference to a famous seafood seasoning:

0902oldbayseasoning

Amusing, yes. But a hell of a stretch.

Hey, we love puns. But we think the reporter went overboard here.

As you might expect, though, many readers loved it.

Raiderfan commented:

Way to make the best of an article that you probably didn’t want to write! This was very good.

dp_absecon wrote:

Loved the story - sent it out to friends under the headline “How to Write a Newspaper Story”. Keep up the good work!

Professor Smart E. Pants wrote:

Boy, I bet he was real crabby when he got busted.
SouthJerseySteve wrote:
Forget jail time, drop this guy into a pot of boiling water!
We’re unclear whether SouthJerseySteve is referring to the thief or to the reporter…

2 Responses to “Can one story have too many puns?”

  1. Scott Pytlik Says:

    Yeah, I can write a story and then go on and comment on my story under 6 different names too! It doesn’t mean my story is good, haha.

    I love creative writing but this was a bit much.

  2. Michelle McCleary-Siss Says:

    “We think the reporter went overboard.” Overboard? Ha!

 


©2004-2010 - Visual Editors, NFP